kirkland signature tiramisu cake at the Costco bakery

What I found at Costco: Tiramisu cake

Can Kirkland Signature's giant tiramisu stand up to a restaurant's?
Share Button

What I found at … is a series that tests and vets intriguing store-bought foodie finds. 

What: Kirkland Signature tiramisu bar cake
Where: Bakery department refrigerated case
Cost: $15.99 for a 2.37 lb cake

Q: Can Kirkland's giant tiramisu stand up to a restaurant-quality dessert?

I'm not too keen on super sweet treats and seek out those that strike a balance of sweet and bitter. Tiramisu happens to be one of them. You don't feel too guilty about indulging in a slice after feasting on pasta and braised meats. Light-as-air sweetened mascarpone cheese, eggs and sugar are tamed by the bitter bite of espresso-soaked lady fingers and a generous dusting of cocoa powder. Coffee and chocolate also pair well with cream, making tiramisu one of those perfect desserts. 

Tiramisu in the bakery case at Costco
The name tiramisu is derived from an Italian phrase that translates as "pick me up" 

Browsing Costco Iwilei one evening, I was intrigued to find a nearly bare shelf in the bakery department — usually a sign that something is good. It was the new tiramisu bar cake, and only three remained. I knew I had to see if this was the gigantic tiramisu cake of my dreams. 

Slice of Costco tiramisu

At an Italian restaurant, $16 might be enough for two small slices of tiramisu — not expensive but not cheap, either. No store knows value like Costco Wholesale, so it is not surprising to discover you can slice this 38-ounce cake into seven 5.42-ounce portions, which would be comparable to a restaurant serving. 

A: No, but ...

The Kirkland Signature tiramisu cake is an extreme value for the money. It's also very moist and full of coffee liqueur. But that's where its benefits end. 

Tiramisu cake fork

This cake leans far too sweet for my liking and lacks that generous dusting of cocoa powder that would instantly distinguish it from other desserts. After a few bites, I find myself giving up on the sugar overload. 

If you're willing to try it for yourself, I recommend eating your slice with a shot of espresso to balance out the sweetened mascarpone cheese and coffee liqueur. 


Hungry for more finds? Here's the rest of the series:
What I found at Safeway: Mickey Mouse ice cream bars
What I found at Costco: Herdez guacamole salsa
What I found at Costco: Keto-friendly egg bites
What I found at Foodland: Detroit-style pizza
What I found at Costco: Cheeseburger
What I found at Jack in the Box: Teriyaki steak bowls
What I found at Costco: Sous vide pork belly
What I found at Costco: Beef bulgogi mandoo
What I found at Target: Museum of Ice Cream pints
What I found at Costco: 505 Southwestern street tacos
What I found at Costco: Acai bowl
What I found at Zippy's: Mochiko chicken mix
What I found at Costco: Ultimate Blueberry Margarita
What I found at Burger King: Flamin' Hot Mac n' Cheetos
What I found at Costco: Chocolate lava cake 
What I found at Marukai: Milk tea that looks like water
What I found at Costco: Microwave pho 
What I found at Costco: Raoh tonkotsu ramen